|
GRAND PRIX:
China : So, Farewell V10s
by Winston D'Arcy |
26.10.05
The Chinese GP was the end of the V10 era which began in 1989 when McLaren
fielded the Honda powered MP4/5 and Williams the Renault powered FW12C in
the Brazilian GP. Ayrton Senna took pole for McLaren but collided with Ferrari's
Gerhard Berger, so Nigel Mansell took a surprise victory in the beautiful,
John Barnard designed, Ferrari 640. This tipo introduced the semi-automatic
gearbox to F1 but it had been very unreliable throughout the weekend, hence
the surprise.
Ayrton Senna took the first GP victory for an engine of this configuration
in the San Marino GP a month later, his team-mate Alain Prost was second
and Thierry Boutsen fourth in a Williams Renault FW12C. This set the scene
for the year and these two teams finished first and second in the Constructors'
Championship. 1991 would be the only year between then and now when an engine
of an alternative configuration (Honda V12) would win the title. Ferrari
were the last team to abandon their beloved V12s, but eventually they saw
the light and fielded the V10 powered 310 for Michael Schumacher and Eddie
Irvine in 1996.
Renault are the most successful V10 engine manufacturer, having powered
other marques to six Constructors' titles before this season, so it was
fitting that they secured the final title of the era for themselves in China.
They did so in the best possible way with 2005 World Champion Fernando Alonso
taking a dominant win. Of course, the V10 will live on in rev-limited form;
but only in the back of the Squadra Toro Rosso (neé Minardi) cars
for now, but there are rumours that a restricted V10 may prove to be a better
bet in 2006 than the new 2.4 litre V8s - the test drivers' enthusiasm for
the new units having been underwhelming thus far.
Talking about Minardi, there was a great deal of sentimentality about how
sad it was that this brave little team, the F1 minnows, were finishing.
Their record shows that they entered 346 races, their best results being
three fourth places (two of them in 1991) and led just one lap of one GP
- Pierluigi Martini in the 1989 Portugese GP as a result of pit stops. Their
best year in the Constructors' Championship was 1993 when they finished
eighth with seven points. You might argue that their role has been to nurture
young talent, but the record shows that just four drivers (Nannini, Fisichella,
Trulli and Alonso) out of 37 went on to win a GP and one to become World
Champion.
Interestingly all of their "winners" subsequently drove for Benetton/Renault,
which suggests than it's Flav who's the Machiavellian talent spotter and
found the money to place them in a team which has never really been anything
more than a refuge for rent-a-drivers. If there was ever any sign of them
moving forward, or if they've ever used talent or quick thinking to take
advantage of a situation then I've missed it, unlike the last call of Ken
Tyrrell's career to brim Salo's car which enabled him run non-stop and take
the last points for the once-great marque in the wet 1997 Monaco GP. I shall
shed no crocodile tears for Minardi, they've had 21 years in F1 with nothing
to show for it other than having 21 years in F1.
In China we were also saying goodbye to Sauber, BAR and Jordan, leaving
Williams as the only team whose main business is F1. Jordan/Midland rather
remind me of ATS at times, who in their second incarnation as Rial, did
score two fourth places, two-thirds of Minardi's achievement, but in just
two seasons.
In Japan Renault looked like they had an uphill struggle ahead of them to
match McLaren's pace in China and finally secure the Constructor's title.
They went for it - taking upgraded chassis to this final race of the formula
and it paid off; they also had the luxury of fresh engines which would only
have to do one race. Alonso qualified on pole with Fisi second ahead of
the McLarens - Kimi in third and Pablo in fourth. Schuey was sixth and Rubens
eighth.
Qualifying reminded us that if Istanbul Park is the best Tilkedrome, then
Shanghai is definitely the worst, it almost seems that it was designed to
bring out the worst in a modern F1 car - they were wallowing around in low
gears, off the throttle, for an eternity and looked utterly ridiculous.
It would certainly improve things if they cut off that stupid squiggle after
the start!
Schuey seemed out of sorts in China again, maybe he just can't get his head
round the stupid circuit. He dithered into Albers's path on the warm up
and both cars were severely damaged, Schuey having to start from the pit
lane for the second year running. The Renaults did a fantastic job at the
start, Alonso blasting off into the lead and Fisi getting in front of the
McLarens and holding them up whilst the other Renault disappeared into the
distance; at the end of lap 19 he had a near 20 second lead, then the safety
car was deployed.
Montoya's McLaren had ripped over a drain cover, which punched holes
into a number of the cars important bits - though fortunately none of
Pablo's, in what could have been a very serious incident. The cars pitted
and Fisi backed the field up á la McLaren at Spa, but the FIA had
made it clear that this would no longer be tolerated and he was given
a drive-through penalty.
Schuey's terrible season came to an end after 22 laps when he spun out
in the first safety car period, but his third place in the Drivers' Championship
was secured when Montoya retired.
When the safety car went in Alonso headed off into distance again and
his lead was up to 13 seconds when the safety car came out again when
Karthikeyan had a huge shunt - smashing his car to pieces against the
tyre wall. The Indian sat in the shattered car for a long time with flames
licking around it, the marshalls seemingly inactive. Happily he was unscathed.
The top four dived into the pits and the McLaren crew used the opportunity
to get Raikkonen ahead of Fisichella. Rubens had been running in fourth
place, but under heavy pressure from Webber he went wide and the Australian
went through followed by Button. A lap later Coulthud did him and he continued
to fall down through the field, finally coming home 12th behind Monteiro,
a sad way to end his career as a Ferrari driver, especially in a race
he won last year. Monteiro has been the best of a poor set of rookies
this year - talent seemingly not being the major factor taken into account
with any but Liuzzi - and he was disappointing.
Alonso won and seemed even more pleased to have clinched the Constructors'
title than he did the Drivers', nailing his V10 whilst parked in the pit
lane until it caught fire! Raikkonen was second and Ralf took his second
podium for Toyota having run in second place before his final pit stop
dropped him behind the Finn. This moves Ralf ahead of his team-mate in
the drivers' Championship, Trulli having outshone him for much of the
year - it's amazing how Ralf picked it up at the season-end!
Christian Klien, surely the most improved driver of the year, took an
excellent fifth place, with Ruben's replacement Massa sixth in his last
race for Sauber. Webber took a solid seventh place for Williams and Button
the last point in the last race for BAR, this week's excuse being that
he'd lost three places under the safety car. It would be interesting to
know how much their F1 adventure cost BAT and how many zillions of fags
it represents.
So, the 2005 season came to an end, notable for Ferrari's fall from grace,
occasional outbreaks of racing, the virtual disappearance of independent
teams, Alonso and Renault's well-earned titles, beating the fast but fragile
McLarens and their fallible drivers. We tifosi must hope that next year
a new formula means a new opportunity - Forza Ferrari!
Footnote
In my pre-season preview I predicted the results on this year's Constructors'
Championship based on pre-season testing times (neither Jordan or Minardi
did any tests which were meaningful for comparison). It isn't too far
out, especially when you consider that Ferrari would have been fourth
but for the USGP. BAR and Toyota are a good bit out, but the former did
suffer disqualification at San Marino, a subsequent two race ban and its
knock-on effects.
|
Predicted |
Actual |
1 |
Renault |
Renault |
2 |
McLaren |
McLaren |
3 |
BAR |
Ferrari |
4 |
Ferrari |
Toyota |
5 |
Williams |
Williams |
6 |
Red Bull |
BAR |
7 |
Toyota |
Red Bull |
8 |
Sauber |
Sauber |
We would like to dedicate this last GP report
of the year to Frank Bott who wrote the final report last year. Sadly,
it was to be his last as he passed away in February.
We're missing you Franco! - Ed.
" A
bad end to a very disappointing season. Today, we failed to get either car
home in the points. Given that situation, we can say that third place in
the Constructors’ and the same result with Michael in the Drivers’
is pretty much of a miracle. I hope we can put this year behind us as quickly
as possible and to be back for the start of the next season in a position
to once again aim for the top .”
“This
weird ending pretty much sums up our season. As far as the warm-up lap is
concerned, I was just warming up my tyres when suddenly I felt a big bang.
I have not seen the incident on video yet, so I will not comment further.
Then, during the Safety Car period, I spun simply because my tyres were
completely worn and they were very cold, so when someone braked ahead of
me, I had to brake as well and went off the track. Now, let’s look
ahead to putting things right next season.”
“A
sad race, but I want to thank everyone in the team, both here and those
back in Maranello. We have had a fantastic years. I learnt a lot and it
is Ferrari that has given me the chance to build something for the future.
I am grateful for that and I am sure we will be friends for ever.”
RACE
RESULTS - CHINESE GP
53 Laps. Weather : Sunny |
Classified: |
Pos |
Driver |
Team |
|
Time |
1. |
Alonso |
Renault |
(M) |
1h39:53.618
|
2. |
Raikkonen |
McLaren |
(M) |
+ 4.015
|
3. |
R. Schumacher |
Toyota |
(M) |
+ 25.376
|
4. |
Fisichella |
Renault |
(M) |
+ 26.114
|
5. |
Klien |
Red Bull |
(M) |
+ 31.839
|
6. |
Massa |
Sauber |
(M) |
+ 36.400
|
7. |
Webber |
Williams |
(M) |
+ 36.842
|
8. |
Button |
BAR |
(M) |
+ 41.249
|
9. |
Coulthard |
Red Bull |
(M) |
+ 44.247
|
10. |
Villeneuve |
Sauber |
(M) |
+ 59.977
|
11. |
Monteiro |
Jordan |
(B) |
+ 1:24.648
|
12. |
Barrichello |
Ferrari |
(B) |
+ 1:32.812
|
13. |
Pizzonia |
Williams |
(M) |
+ 1 lap
|
14. |
Doornbos |
Minardi |
(B) |
+ 1 lap |
15. |
Trulli |
Toyota |
(M) |
+ 1 lap |
16. |
Albers |
Jordan |
(B) |
+ 4 laps |
NC |
Sato |
BAR |
(M)) |
DNF |
NC |
Karthikeyan |
Jordan |
(B) |
DNF |
NC |
Montoya |
McLaren |
(M) |
DNF |
NC |
M. Schumacher |
Ferrari |
(B) |
DNF |
World Championship Standing, Round 19 |
Drivers: |
|
Constructors: |
1. |
Alonso |
133 |
|
1. |
Renault |
191 |
2. |
Raikkonen |
112 |
|
2. |
McLaren |
182 |
3. |
M. Schumacher |
62 |
|
3. |
Ferrari |
100 |
4. |
Montoya |
60 |
|
4. |
Toyota |
88 |
5. |
Fisichella |
58 |
|
5. |
Williams |
66 |
6. |
R Schumacher |
45 |
|
6. |
BAR |
38 |
7. |
Trulli |
43 |
|
7. |
Red Bull |
34 |
8. |
Barrichello |
38 |
|
8. |
Sauber |
20 |
9. |
Button |
37 |
|
9. |
Jordan |
12 |
10. |
Webber |
36 |
|
10. |
Minardi |
7 |
11. |
Heidfeld |
28 |
|
|
|
|
12. |
Coulthard |
24 |
|
|
|
|
13. |
Massa |
11 |
|
|
|
|
14.= |
Klien |
9 |
|
|
|
|
14.= |
Villeneuve |
9 |
|
|
|
|
16. |
Monteiro |
7 |
|
|
|
|
17. |
Wurz |
6 |
|
|
|
|
18. |
Karthikeyan |
5 |
|
|
|
|
19.= |
Albers |
4 |
|
|
|
|
19.= |
de la Rosa |
4 |
|
|
|
|
21. |
Friesacher |
3 |
|
|
|
|
22. |
Pizzonia |
2 |
|
|
|
|
23.= |
Liuzzi |
1 |
|
|
|
|
23.= |
Sato |
1 |
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
Click here
to return to the Ferrari Happenings page.
|
Senna
took the first V10 win, for Honda... |
|
|
...and
Alonso the last for Renault, though Toro Rosso will carry on with
them |
|
|
Ferrari
went V10 in 1996, Schuey taking the first win at Barcelona |
|
|
Pierlugi
Martini drove Minardi's only lap in the lead of a GP |
|
|
Ken
Tyrrell made a racer's call to score his team's last-ever two points |
|
|
Rial
had 66% of Minardi's best results in less than 10% of the seasons |
|
|
Renault
were 1&2 in Qualifying in China |
|
|
Schuey
will have been glad to see the sun set on the 2005 season |
|
|
Fisi
did a great job of holding up the grey hordes... |
|
|
...whilst
Alonso disappeared into the distance |
|
|
This
was Karthikeyan's Jordan |
|
|
No
happy ending for Rubens's Ferrari career |
|
|
Alonso
celebrates Renault's Constructors' title - with a little help from
Flav |
|
|
Klien
was most improved driver of the year |
|
|
Schuey's
2006 team-mate scored points in his last race for Sauber |
|
|
End
of year pic for class of '05, but where's Ralf? |
|
|
|
|
|
pics by
Ferrari Media, XPB, LAT, Sutton, Reuters, Nigel Bland & unknown |
|